Here is presented the REVIEW of academician Velihov on article of Smorodov's and Galiahmetod's "The experimental detection of neutrons at shock
compression deuterium bubble in a viscous liquid". Unfortunately, I had no opportunity personally to familiarize with this review in a paper variant signed by E.P.
Velihov, but I made a copy from the INTERNET. Therefore I make responsible for reliability of the text of the review and the instruction of its authorship
to owners of a site - Smorodov and Galiahmetov.

I nonrandom impose a responsibility on owners of a site - more comical and inconsistent review is difficult
for presenting - such specially will not compose.
__With great difficulty I can believed, that the person, owning logic, could write it.__

Therefore, if misters Velihov and Altshuler did not write it, then I make one's apologies, but if you its author, then now, Evgenie Pavlovich, you not can have the resentment - my comments to it are given in the end, after caustic remarks of Smorodov's and Galiahmetov's.

The R E V I E W

to article of Smorodov's E.A., Galiakhmetov's R.N. "About an opportunity of initiation of reaction of nuclear synthesis at pulsations of gas spheres in a liquid", presented to an editorial board of magazine "The news of HIGH SCHOOLS: Problems of the energy engineering" .

The theme of presented article corresponds to a objective of magazine.

At preparation of work in brackets the second working name of article is specified: "The experimental detection of neutrons at shock compression deuterium bubble in a viscous liquid".
In such a way authors wish to draw attention of a researchers to a consider problem.

In work the authors enumerate of the supplemental data on reaction of synthesis, say about the some methods, which allow to do of the such reactions. Further the basic attention in article is given to the description of non-stationary movement of border of liquid and gas phases. One can notice, that the mentioned equation is fair at the strong physical restrictions imposed on a choice of mathematical model as of a liquid, so and of the gas. To the description of a problem of reaction of nuclear synthesis these equations are of little use. In the conclusion of the article we are given the schematical description of experimental installation. To the presented work there are remarks:

1.. In article the equation (1) on page 6 named to as equation of Nolting-Neppiras. In the scientific literature this equation is known as equation of Rayleigh-Lamb-Plesset's. There are many works devoted to a numerical method of integration of this equation and discussion of results of calculation for different approximations the equations of a condition of gas. In opinion of the reviewer, authors of article were not engaged in the numerical decision of this task.

2. The equation (1) describes non-stationary movement of boundary of a liquid and gas phase. It is written down in the assumption, which not can executed in physical model of process. Borders of liquid area are flat surfaces, thus it is impossible to provide a condition of sphericity of process. At strong impacts the boundary of two environments at once loses the spherical form.

3. The authors of work employ of the Van der Waals equation for the description of the equation of a condition of real gas. However, how it is known, this equation is unsuitable for calculations of thermodynamic parameters at great values of pressure, it only qualitatively reflects real processes.

4. Reasonings in article concerning limits of applicability of the molecular-kinetic theory have no real substantiation. Only the molecular-kinetic theory gives a full explanation of all existent processes.

5.
Judge by the name, this work is devoted to condemnation ^{*)} of the results of experiment. However in article the
schematical description of experimental installation is given, there is no discussion of a series of experiments.

I suppose, that the presented article of the Smorodov's E.A., Galiakhmetov's R.N. "About an opportunity of initiation of reaction of nuclear synthesis at pulsations of gas spheres in a liquid" does not contain new scientific data. Work is not recommended to the publication in scientific magazine "News of HIGH SCHOOLS. Problems of the energy engineering".

The such full and irrevocable refusal. Soon we shall receive similar of UFN (the russian magazine "Advances in Physical Sciences") and we shall necessarily place his on a site.

^{
}

About it we write on the main page of a site. We shall not repeat, that the "suitable" equations no exist in general.

"In opinion of the reviewer, authors of article were not engaged in the numerical decision of this task". In article we showed the results of calculations and the detailed algorithm of the numerical decision of the equation . In Excel even the schoolboy can make it, if he not play truant lessons of computer science.

"At strong impacts the boundary of two environments at once loses the spherical form". The reviewer have such profound physical intuition! As Kurchatov! Loses the spherical form, and all here, though you knock by the head in a brick wall.

**The remark 3.
**

**The remark 4.
**

**The remark 5.
**

"The series of experiments" we too have. Yes only "the opening by means the statistics" is necessary for those, which do experiments so, that the effect is shown on the verge of sensitivity of devices or hide by noise, how it was in experiments of the group of the academician R.I. Nigmatulin's.